Howard, James. Letter to the editor. Columbia (Maryland) Flier, April 1, 2004.
According to your March 25 article, “CA breaking law, Russell says,” Barbara Russell claims the Columbia Association is violating state law by closing meetings improperly.
The Maryland Homeowners Association Act defines a homeowners association as an organization with the right to enforce the terms of any declaration recorded among land records.
The covenants for each individual village only assign rights of enforcement to the individual village, making each of them a homeowners association. However, the Columbia Association, lacking these rights, is not a homeowners association and therefore not subject to the act.
The Columbia Association, further, may feel free to remove non-members of the association from the meeting. Under the Columbia Association charter and bylaws, the only persons who are members of the corporation are the 10 members of the Columbia Council. No other person has any right to attend what is, by law, a private meeting of a private corporation.
While closing the meetings may be poor policy and lead to more questions than answers, it does not appear to be illegal.