Skip to content

Death is expensive, too

Howard, James. Letter to the editor. Hamilton (Ohio) Journal-News, October 18, 2000.

On Oct. 7, Ms. Shelley Moore wrote a letter discussing applications of the death penalty. Moore claimed that it was unfair to allow criminals to live off tax money.

What Ms. Moore does not state is that it is more expensive to execute than to let him or her live. The average cost of house a criminal for one year is $20,000 while the average cost of trial and appeals in a capital case exceeds $2 million.

Even if a convicted felon lived for 100 years in prison, it would still cost the public less to house rather than execute.

Further, the death penality has a high degree of failure. On Oct. 2, Virginia Gov. James Gilmore pardoned Earl Washington Jr. after DNA tests cleared Mr. Washington for a 1982 rape and murder. After his conviction, he spent 17 years in prison and was sentenced to death. Virginia officials have claimed to never err in capital cases in the past.

This is also why Illinois has declared a moratorium on executions. Since 1976, half of those on Death Row in Illinois have been released after DNA or other new testing methods proved their innocence. Between 1900 and 1992, 416 innocent persons were given death sentences and 23 of them were executed.

The death penalty also unfairly attacks poor and minority groups. African-Americans are 12 percent of the U.S. population but are 43 percent of the prisoners on death row. African-Americans also make up 60 percent of all murder victims but 83 percent of the victims in capital cases are white.

Moreover, 90 percent of capital defendants are unable to afford legal representation and must accept a court appointed attornet who, in some states, is paid below minimum wage for their services.

Finally, FBI studies have shown that the death penalty is not an effective deterrent. It has shown that states without a death penalty maintain significantly lower murder rates than those which do. On a grander scale, the United States has one of the highest murder rates among Western nations but is one of the few Western nations with a death penalty.

The death penalty should not be given as a sentence and every state should ban the death penalty to prevent further travesties of justice from occuring.