Howard, James. “Filling holes in the Ohio districts.” University of Maryland Diamondback, September 18, 2002.
After Jim Traficant and Tony Hall left office, Ohio got two vacant seats in Congress. Ohio Gov. Bob Taft has announced he will not call special elections to fill the seats until a new Congress is seated in January. In response, the American Civil Liberties Union sued the governor, claiming both the state and national constitutions require special elections.
The ACLU is right. However, a special election is time-consuming and drains money. Gov. Taft cited the $800,000 cost per district for not calling a special election. The Columbus Dispatch agreed, calling the expenditure and ACLU suit a waste. The Akron Beacon-Journal also called a special election “essentially pointless.”
In the case of a vacancy in the House of Representatives, the expenditure can be silly, as the term of office will not exceed two years. In the cases of Traficant and Hall, the term will be less than five months, even if new representatives were sworn in today. Elections are costly and time-consuming. Modern technology may have sped up the mechanical portions of the electoral process, but campaigning cannot be helped by technology.
However, the people of Ohio’s 3rd and 17th Districts deserve representation in Congress. The districts will still have constituent services provided by the Clerk of the House, but will have no voting member. As most major legislation is passed near the end of a term, the missing vote is even more important in such a closely divided Congress.
I propose a constitutional amendment allowing each state’s executive to appoint a temporary replacement until the next general election can be held.
The 17th Amendment to The Bill of Rights permits a governor to appoint a temporary senator if that state’s legislature grants that power to the governor. The governor then must hold a special election with the next general election to fill the open seat. This power was used in Missouri to appoint Sen. Jean Carnahan to the seat her husband, Mel Carnahan, won.
The amendment I propose would have a similar effect on vacancies in the House of Representatives. Possible options include governor’s appointment with confirmation by the state’s legislature, election by the legislature or even a special election, as is required now. The key is it offers each state the ability to solve the problem locally and in its own best interests.
This problem is infrequent and each legislature may exercise oversight of its governor and ensure that abuses do not go unchecked. Restrictions may also be imposed at the state level. For instance, if a seat in Ohio’s legislature is vacated, the members of that last elected member’s party may elect a replacement to the office. This gives the voters some level of assurance their new representative will be ideologically similar to their previous representative.
More importantly, this allows Congress to be reconstituted in the event of a disaster. The past year has shown how gravely ill-prepared the United States is with respect to terrorism. Were a significant number of Congressmen incapacitated, the Senate can be reformed by appointment but would remain hamstrung by the missing House of Representatives.
The procedural gains made from the amendment are enough to warrant its adoption. Still, this may take some years. And until it passes, this problem will still arise from time to time, leaving more than a half-million people without representation in the House of Representatives.
By and large, constitutional amendments expand the rights of citizens. Oddly, this proposal, while purely procedural, does protect the rights of voters and citizens by ensuring them a place in Congress without causing a financial burden on the state.