Howard, James. “Free speech takes precedence.” University of Maryland Diamondback, April 20, 2001.
Mike Sarzo’s column (“Free speech not the only issue,” April 13) managed to miss every mark. It is grossly irresponsible to suggest The Diamondback not run the David Horowitz ad. Sarzo, in words repeated in a pull quote, claims, “College is often called a marketplace of ideas, and a student newspaper is one of the most common places where that marketplace takes shape.” Sarzo then turns around and says, “Not every opinion can be published, nor should it.”
This is where Sarzo goes wrong. Despite the fact that advertising copy has been ruled free speech by the Supreme Court in New York Times Co. v. Sullivan (1964), he goes on to say, “The Diamondback could very well have refused to run the ad, and Horowitz would have had no recourse.” Oops.
The issue of free speech is much larger than Sarzo claims. The issue of free speech is central to the argument. Similar to Sarzo, Michael J. O’Connor reminds readers in the March 12 edition of The Minnesota Daily that “The university, as well as society at large, needs to constantly renew its commitment to the right of free speech.” In a nation where speech is suppressed on a daily basis because it is unpopular (pornography) or dangerous (weapons designs), Americans need a reminder that just because they do not like something does not mean it should go away.
O’Connor also points out free speech is often a hindrance to the community because it can prevent smooth operation in corporate or educational settings. Whether by choice or by accident, Sarzo has fallen into this deadly trap.
Often universities are accused of being ivory towers with no real connection to the outside world. Often derogatory, this is a blessing in disguise. As a result, the university setting is the ideal shop for discussion of new, radical or unpopular ideas without the threat of mainstream interference. Ideas can be freely debated and refined until an idea is perfected or discarded; the best float to the surface leaving the unfit masses behind.
But universities are not ivory towers. They have been overrun by rank commercialism and political correctness. The May 2001 issue of Harper’s reports that 60 percent of television investigators have seen advertisers try to kill their stories. There is no question corporate sponsorship causes the media to falter in its public responsibility. But it also causes intellectual curiosity to suffer. The most obvious example of this lies in the auto industry’s own sponsorship of alternative fuel research.
Political correctness, however, is a guided missile to the heart of research. By explicitly limiting language and thought, political correctness is a death knell to all in its way. Affirmative action (another action taken in the name of reparations) and modern “anti-inflammatory language” are a burden to intellectual pursuits. By placing artificial and arbitrary limits on acceptability, certain avenues can no longer be pursued.
The Horowitz ad strikes back at both these barriers. As an advertisement, it stresses the nature of college presses. Questions arise concerning editorial autonomy. If an editor at a college newspaper has the ability to kill an advertisement, as does Diamondback editor Matt Sheehan, what safe guards prevent the sales department from killing a story that less than flatters a sponsor? After all, a precedent has already been set. The sales department and the editorial department should have no authority over each other.
The Horowitz ad also flies in the face of political correctness. On its face, political correctness is a mental crutch for those who cannot fathom either their own or other’s self-sufficiency. And Horowitz intentionally challenges political correctness through the use of inflammatory language. Suggesting that blacks should be grateful for their history because it allowed their ancestors to come to America where they now enjoy one the highest standards of living, Horowitz gives the opposite of the common wisdom without distorting the facts.
Sheehan quoted George Orwell after running the ad. Orwell was a strong believer in personal liberties. In the face of possible recriminations from those who are not grateful for America’s gift of liberty, Sheehan realized the right of freedom of speech is paramount and applicable.
Even if this were not true, refusing to run the advertisement would have shown disrespect and been a disservice to the campus community. If The Diamondback had refused, the only opinion expressed would have been contempt for the readership.
Victor Navasky, publisher of The Nation, discusses the Horowitz ad in the April 23, 2001, issue. In it, he states, “We start with the presumption that we will accept advertising even if the views exposed are repugnant to some of the editors … we have confidence that our readers are then capable of determining for themselves what views to accept and reject.” And through a similar policy by Sheehan, The Diamondback has earned the faith and trust of its readers.