Skip to content

Freedom of thought

Howard, James. Letter to the editor. Minnesota Daily, March 19, 2001.

When Michael J. O’Connor’s editorial, “Free speech promotes flourishing of ideas, creativity” (March 12), discussing free thinking in America’s universities was published, I was pleased to see someone taking responsibility for the intellectual aspects of education. But Mr. O’Connor misses several fundamental points in his argument.

For decades, public high school has been stomping on independent thought, and not without reason. The mind factories have produced generation after generation of fine citizens who would not question authority, be that of their government or employer.

For instance, earlier this month, a Plymouth, Michigan student wrote an article for his school newspaper claiming that Black History Month promoted racism. After a public outcry, the school superintendent announced the journalism teacher would be disciplined. As of yet, a decision about discipline for the author is unknown. This hardly encourages free, rational thought and debate.

Of course, it does not help when the leaders of the educational establishment do not understand the rules. Following the Columbine massacre, ten students in Allen, Texas wore black armbands to protest restrictive policies. One student was suspended. When another of the students, Jennifer Boccia, presented a school official with a copy of the 1969 Supreme Court decision allowing students to wear black armbands to protest the Vietnam War, the official ran the paper through a shredder. Schools are also notorious for attacking students who dress off from the norm. Colored hair, black clothing and makeup, and anything else nonconformative puts you on the short bus to suspension. This has been especially true in the wake of the Columbine massacre as evidenced by Jon Katz’ continuing work, “Voices From the Hellmouth.”

We’d like to think the examples above are the exceptions but these are just the examples I had on hand. Indeed, this is the standard. Too many in the public educational system have retired on the job. They are unfit to be teaching and instilling values into the children of America. They need to go before they ruin another generation.

Archival Note

The preserved author archive also contains Problems run deep for educational system. These are related versions with different wording, published in different newspapers. Both publication records are retained and linked as versions, rather than described as unrelated essays.