Howard, James and Howard Quach. “Microsoft deal not a wise idea.” University of Maryland Diamondback, November 8, 2000.
The U. of Maryland is proposing a $20 per semester fee for MS software access, regardless of usage.
On Wednesday, November 1st, the University of Maryland Diamondback reported on a proposal to charge a $20 per semester fee to all students in exchange for Microsoft products being given free to all students at the University. On the surface, this may seem an enticing deal, but soon the “Microsoft tax” looks very sketchy.
There are several thousand students on campus who either do not own computers, or who do not own computers powerful enough to take advantage of the software being provided. However, these students will still be required to pay the $20 per semester fee, regardless of the fact they have no need for the product.
Additionally, many students on campus choose not to use Microsoft software. They may be Apple Macintosh or Unix users. For Macintosh users, paying for Microsoft Windows is silly since it will not run on a Macintosh. For Unix users, paying for Microsoft Word is equally silly since Word will not run on these computers. Still others simply choose Corel WordPerfect over Word, or Qualcomm Eudora over Microsoft Outlook. However, these students will still be required to pay the $20 per semester fee, despite the fact they chose not to use the software.
And still others already own the software because they bought it or it came with their computers. Again, these students will still be required to pay the $20 per semester fee, effectively paying for the software twice.
Other students on campus are crying foul because they fear certain features of the Microsoft software will become part of their class requirements. Many features of Microsoft programs violate accepted industry standards and are incompatible with other tools including network protocols which power the Internet. If students are forced to use this software as part of their class work, they may find themselves unable to interact with others around the world.
This mass standardization also leaves the students vulnerable to technological problems. As has been recently shown, a single email virus like “I Love You” can halt operations at entire companies for hours or even days. This is only a problem when computers are identical. In 1988, the Morris Internet Worm attacked Digital Equipment Corporation VAX computers running 4BSD and Sun Microsystems computers running SunOS. However, the vast array of equipment types on the Internet at the time prevented more than a small percentage of systems from being affected.
Most telling, though, is that Microsoft still has not learned from its consent decree. Before the consent decree, Microsoft charged individual computer manufacturers a flat fee for each computer shipped, regardless of whether Microsoft software shipped with it. Similarly, Microsoft intends to charge each student, regardless of whether they want, use, need, or have even already paid for the software.
If the University of Maryland is interested in providing high-technology tools to the students at a reduced rate, a better solution would be to allow students to sign up voluntarily. While providing the same reduced rate to students, it would not force students to pay for something they do not need or want.
Archival Note
The preserved author archive also contains The New Microsoft Tax. The recovered bodies are identical apart from their citations. Both publication records are retained and linked as versions, rather than described as unrelated essays.