Howard, James. “Moderation, Slashdot’s Biggest Mistake.” OSOpinion, June 1, 2000. http://www.osopinion.com/Opinions/JamesHoward/JamesHoward2.html.
Slashdot’s moderation scheme may first seem like the solution to spammers and others who merely wish to disrupt the regular discourse. However, Slashdot made an awful mistake and placed the power of moderation in the hands of its own users. This led to abuse after abuse of the power and too many comments are misfiled.
While this abuse has continued for several years, we will look at recent examples. BSD articles are usually hotbeds of poor moderation. In the recent Roots of BSD, a poster commented that BSD is the result of a freak fork in the Solaris code. This comment was moderated up “Interesting” despite the fact there was no truth to the post. In OpenBSD, Reductionist Design a poster compared OpenBSD and Red Hat Linux’s security by looking at recent security exploits. This comment was marked “Informative” once, “Funny” three times, “Flamebait” once, and “Overrated” once. It seems like the moderators cannot agree even on this one. When Slashdot ran Mac OS Mach/BSD Kernel Inseparable, the editor made a small mistake. After Slashdot editor HeUnique announced that he had corrected the posting, he was moderated down, “Offtopic.” It is nice to see that even Slashdot editors are not immune to poor moderation.
Of course, name dropping is an excellent way to gain moderation points. When a poster claimed Alan Cox had written papers on how bsd has repeatedly imitated or stole source code from linux, he was moderated up “Interesting.” However, Alan Cox has never written such papers.
Another quick route to moderation hell is mentioning KDE or GNOME. Both sides in the KDE/GNOME war are very vocal and never willing to take an argument from the other side. When a poster recently complained about the number of warnings and problems caused by GNOME, he was quickly moderated down “Troll,” despite the accuracy of his complaints. And when KDevelop 1.2 was announced, a Motif bashing comment was labeled “Insightful.”
In the article, Napster Hurts Album Sales?, the very first comment read, Is it/The first post?!?. While this comment was clearly “Offtopic,” it was rated as “Troll.” The net effect is the same; however, it shows that moderators do not understand the proper classification system. Further, sifting through Slashdot stories, most so-called “first posts” are rated “Troll” despite the lack of any provacative content.
While I have only provided a few glaring examples of where moderation has failed in the past couple of weeks, it is obvious to many that moderation has not worked. Many actively attack moderation or maintain seperate “sids” that discuss moderation and its faults. Others have started similar websites that have done away with moderation completely. And still others have reworked moderation on their own site. While I cannot offer a viable solution to the moderation issue, it is plainly clear that the current situation is not optimal and should be redressed.