Howard, James. “President Bush’s ABM Program.” Kuro5hin, May 3, 2001. http://www.kuro5hin.org/?op=displaystory&sid=2001/5/3/10215/30545.
On Tuesday, at the National Defense University in Washington, President Bush announced plans for a new missile defense program. This program, similiar to President Reagan’s Star Wars or Strategic Defense Initiative, plans to create a “nuclear umbrella” to protect the United States from foreign nuclear attack.
The United States signed the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty in 1972 and has stood by it since. The Treaty prevents the United States and Russia from developing technology to stop an incoming nuclear missile. However, President Bush now claims that the world has changed enough to throw the ABM Treaty away.
Fundamentally, the Treaty worked to prevent nuclear war. If a nation knows it cannot stop its opponent’s retaliation, it is not likely to engage in a nuclear first-strike. Called the theory of mutually assured destruction or deterence thoery, participants in the nuclear game know they can destroy the enemy at the cost of themselves and do not a launch. Without a winner, nuclear war is not worth waging.
President Bush beleives the the time for anti-ballistic missile technology has come. By being the first to ignore the treaty, the United States gives an already overly-nationalistic government in Russia the license to develop its own anti-ballisitic missile plan. Further, Russian military leaders may go further and ignore other disarmament and reduction treaties signed both before and after the fall of the Soviet Union.
President Bush’s argument centers on rogue states like Iraq and North Korea and accidental launches by Russia or China. Except for Russia, none of these nations signed the 1972 ABM Treaty and may be developing anti-ballisitic missile technology. However, President Bush would move farther to protecting American from rogue states by encouraging a new ABM treaty to be signed by all nuclear powers. Russia, interested in maintaining the current ABM Treaty would likely support this effort. This may even be unnecessay, though.
Nuclear threats, as they have been known in the past, may be gone forever. It is unlikely that North Korea will have the technology available to prevent a nuclear strike from the United States within two decades. Iraq will not have the technology for at least fifteen years. Most experts beleive even the United States will need at least three years to produce an effective anti-ballisitic missile program. Some place the time frame closer to eight years.
The modern nuclear threat comes from terrorism. With the information needed to build a modest atomic weapon available in any encyclopedia, the most difficult aspect to nuclear terrorism is the availability of weapons grade nuclear materials. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, nuclear material has remained unaccounted for. Significant amounts nuclear-grade uranium missing from Russian stockpiles. It could have gone on the black market and been sold to any number of the rogue states mentioned before. Nuclear terrorism, against the United States or any other nation, is a holocaust waiting to happen.
More importantly, a missile shield program will not protect against nuclear terrorism, except in the unlikely event a terrorist launches a nuclear weapon against the United States. Far more likely, a terrorist would smuggle a weapon into the United States and detonate the weapon on the ground. This has an added benefit to the terrorist of preventing warnings from going out.
The state of the world has changed significantly in the past decade. Modern nuclear concerns have changed and so have the sources of nuclear threats. President Bush, however, is not living in today’s world. He is not living in his father’s world, either. He is still living in the world of Kennedy and Johnson. Unless the United States takes steps to protect against modern enemies the real enemy will be ourselves.