Skip to content

Saving Slashdot

Howard, James. “Saving Slashdot.” OSOpinion, August 4, 2000. http://www.osopinion.com/Opinions/JamesHoward/JamesHoward4.html.

Several weeks ago, I pointed out that moderation had caused Slashdot to mentally stagnate and showed how perfectly intelligent and insightful comments will be moderated incorrectly due to the Slashdot mentality. However, many readers criticized me for not offering any alternative solutions.

Recently, allegations of a “Karma Mafia” which is controlling the point distribution have turned up. Other allegations of karma points being bought and sold have also come up. Regardless of the truthfulness of these claims, it is clear that moderation does not work. Useful posts are moderated down or are never touched because they do not regurgitate the party line and pure trash, including pornography is being moderated up. As if this were not enough, the early posts in each item come from the Penis Bird Man, OSM, and the others who are there to disrupt meaningful discourse and far too often they succeed.

Unfortunately, the best solution is to remove moderation completely. However, the concept of moderation is so deeply ingrained in the user community that it may be impossible to remove without damaging the community. So I propose an alternative. The current moderation system should be reformed.

First, a user’s karma used to be displayed along with their posting history. This practice should be revived. It would keep users honest and since a high karma can be shown off again, users may be more interested in intelligent posts.

Second, when a post is moderated up or down, the moderator’s user name should also be displayed with each moderation. This would allow the users to see if a group of accounts are under a central control. Using this, it would be infinitely easier to uncover and track moderation abuses. Finally, if a comment is obviously trash but is moderated up, a moderator would probably think twice if he knew he was accountable later.

Finally, remove the anonymous account. It has been often said that the anonymous account promotes free speech, but if you are unwilling to attach your name to a comment, how useful is it? “Anonymous tips” should never be trusted.

There are far too many users for the editors along to handle. Only though direct policing among the users will real action toward cleaning up the content and improving the signal to noise ratio.