Skip to content

The Culture of Affluence Looks at the Cold War

Howard, James. “The Culture of Affluence Looks at the Cold War.” Speech, Undergraduate Research Day, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, April 25, 2001.

Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen.

The legacy of the Cold War affect different social strata in different ways. Today, I will be focusing on how the Cold War affected the self-described “Culture of Affluence.” The Culture of Afflucence is usually described as the upper-middle class. Members have significant disposable income and have been the scorn of those around them for decades. From the Flappers to the Me Generation to today’s Dotcommers, they haver always provided an easy target for ridicule.

A primary and unrelenting source of ridicule has been the cartoons of The New Yorker. Often focusing on the absurd, hints of truth peek through in each one. These cartoons were culled from 1945, following World War II through January of 1961 with the inauguration of John F. Kennedy. Most of the cartoons I will show today originally ran from the late 1940s or early 1950s. This should not suggest a lack of cartoons later.

When focusing on Cold War-related themes from The New Yorker, several clear themes become apparent. There is a simplistic theme focusing on Soviet life. Another theme deals with military life. Other themes touching on Cold War topics also appear including school life and being stranded on a deserted island. The most important theme though is American life and how the upper crust of American society addressed the Cold War. From these few cartoons we will see today, and the hundreds more which littered The New Yorker] pages, we find that the Cold War was simply another modern burden and inconvenience to the Culture of Affluence.

The first topic to be addressed is science. Two caroons, published only a month apart in late 1945 set the tone for this topic. The first, published on November 10, 1945, shows a child who just announced his desire to become a scientist. His mother replies, “But what on earth do you want to be a scientist for, Robert? Isn’t there enough trouble in the world already?” Coming on the heels of the first atomic detonations, made possible primarily through Einstein’s work, this mother was obviously afraid of what new terros science would come up with next.

This fear is confirmed only four weeks later when in the December 8, 1945 issue a mother is purchasing a chemistry set as a Christmas gift. She asks the clerk, “There wouldn’t be any danger of his smashing the atom with this, would there?” This fear of science and what it could bring was common among people for good reason. Only four years after Hiroshima brought a new destruction to bear, America developed thermonuclear weapons. These weapons were so powerful, they need a Hiroshima-style detonation simply to start them off.

This same sentiment is echoed again in the April 16 1955 issue with a cartoon showing a man and woman talking. The caption reads, “Now don’t be so modest, Professor. I’m sure you’ve got something up your sleeve that will blow us all to bits.”

Our next topic for discussion is nuclear annihiliation. First, a cartoon which leaves off the page. Set in a cavern, a couple has built a home there. The caption reads, “We asked ourselves how many places like this would be available if war broke out, and when the owner gave us a decent price on it, we snapped it up.” From October 9, 1948, this predates most of the bomb shelter construction. Howerver, it echoes statistics showing most bomb shelters were built by the upper middle class.

On a related topic, the nature of the inconvenience hits home. After the advent of television, the characters find their priorities at cross-purposes. This cartoon from June 16, 1951 shows a couple at a real estate agent. The caption reads, “We’d like something out of the radioactive zone but within television range.” Obviously, the demands of self-protection are encroaching on the demands of living and this couple feels the pinch. It should be noted this is long before the advent of cable.

The next topic to address is the absurdity of some Cold War actions. This first cartoon, from April 30, 1949 shows a club of older women. This club appeared often throughout the 1940s and 1950s. This cartooon shows a lady in the back ask, “But if we disband our Defend America Committee, won’t Russia take it as a sign of yielding?” We see two things here. First a population which had fought Germany and Japan during the first half of the dcande as war-weary and bored with the prospect of war with Russia. More importantly, we see the value of individual actions against a nation. It is easy to ask if the Soviets would even notice, but if this happened on a large scale across the nation, it would be a sign of weakening and would be noticed.

This next comic from June 27, 1959, plays off major fears. Thoughout the Cold War, each side was suggesting or claiming it was ahead in some field. Stories of a “Bomber Gap” or a “Missile Gap” ran nightly. By the late 1950s, it was clear the Soviets had surpassed the United States in the Space Race. The woman reading a paper says, “No wonder they’re ahead of us. It says here that in the whole of Russia, there is not one single golf course.” Addressing the “Leisure Class,” it suggests that the Soviets work harder and go further as a result. But the absurdity of the connection is striking. In a similar cartoon from the late 1950s, a woman reading a paper claims that America’s Edsel balances the Soviet’s intercontinental ballistic missile to achieve parity. Again, the Leisure Class strikes back.

Our final topic, a staple of Cold War discussions, is the Red Scare. This first cartoon again shows the inconvenience of the Cold War in full force. The genleman says, “I may be a little late tomorrow, Mrs. Searle. I’m having my loyalty checked.” This goes even further; the tone of this cartoon and appearance of the characters sggest thosewho may not entire understand what this means. It is difficult to be certain, however. This cartoon was first published in the September 27, 1947 issue.

The perfect example of Red Scare cartoons comes from the June 28, 1949 issue. The gentleman on the right has presumably asked if there was a room available. The attendant responds, “We haven’t anything right now, but you might try us again in a week or so. There’s a rumor the gentleman in 8-A may not pass his loyalty test.” Set in Washington with the Capitol in the background, this shows how far the Red Scare had pushed through govenrment. The implications, however, are far more reaching. Suppose you suggested someone was a Communist of sympathizer for your own personal benefit. Other cartoons from the 1950s sugggest this happened.

As a side note, this cartoon appeared at the bottom of a page with the top occupied by a book review. The first sentence, “George Orwell’s new novel, Nineteen Eighty-four (Harcourt, Brace) confirms its author in the special, honorable place in our intellectual life.” Some have claimed that Orwell’s novel was not about the year 1984, but about Great Britain in 1948. This pairing suggests it was also about America in the late 1940s.

American Cold War culture was not a single, monolithic force. Many cultures existed within the United States during this time period and each evolved over time. The Culture of Affluence had its own concerns and needs in this time of international struggle. Primarily, as we have seen, these needs often came into conflict with the needs of the State and the needs of living a life worth living. Through these cartoons, the upper-middle class is seen as strangely preoccupied with itself and only itself.

This trend continues today. Yesterday’s Washington Post had a front page article discussing Nww York’s ability to weather a forecasted economic recession. This recession will have been brought on by the downturn in Internet and technology stocks. And last week’s issue of The New Yorker was full of cartoons mocking the Internet bubble and though who sought fortune through it.

Historical Downloads

The original page linked to presentation files and recordings through six legacy /file_download/ URLs. Those file references are preserved in the original recovery bundle, but the corresponding files have not been verified at new addresses and are not linked here.

Later Context

“Jimmy Butler is a Communist and Other Cold War Cartoons” (2016) describes the original presentation and includes a surviving slide embed. It is a later account, separate from this recovered speech text.